Chevron Left
Measuring Causal Effects in the Social Sciences(으)로 돌아가기

코펜하겐대학교의 Measuring Causal Effects in the Social Sciences 학습자 리뷰 및 피드백

207개의 평가
48개의 리뷰

강좌 소개

How can we know if the differences in wages between men and women are caused by discrimination or differences in background characteristics? In this PhD-level course we look at causal effects as opposed to spurious relationships. We will discuss how they can be identified in the social sciences using quantitative data, and describe how this can help us understand social mechanisms....

최상위 리뷰

2021년 1월 10일

This is a challenging course, especially for those who only intend to breeze through the videos alone. Reading the recommended text before and/or after the videos is strongly advised.

2020년 3월 11일

Some Reading Materials such as journal articles on similar methods covered in course would have been a great inclusion as a part of the exercises.

필터링 기준:

Measuring Causal Effects in the Social Sciences의 48개 리뷰 중 1~25

교육 기관: Lisa D

2017년 3월 9일

Unfortunately this course consists of the Professor reading his notes very quickly with rapid listing of concepts and very little time spent explaining complex topics. The quizzes emphasize the terms for various elements of the analysis rather than teaching how to work with the tools to analyze data. There does not seem to be anyone monitoring the course forum and mistakes in quiz questions and questions asked on the forum are not answered or replied to by anyone. I was committed to working with the course but by week 4 it was unfortunately impossible to absorb and there was no way to interact with anyone to get help. I'm sure there is room for improvement on this course and I hope the instructor does work to improve with the course, but currently the course is disappointing as a learning experience.

교육 기관: irene k

2017년 6월 30일

Lecturer extremely difficult to follow. Quiz questions required remembering numbers (!) from weeks earlier. In general a course based on good ideas, all missed in really bad execution of the course.

교육 기관: Tomasz J

2018년 12월 5일

This course makes clear distinction between different approaches to causality with nice graphics. That's good. But my feeling is that it uses explanation methods which are easy to understand only for those... who are already familiar with IV & DID. It's easy to find on the web more straight forward explanations on the web, yet still statistically rigorous.

While explanation level is always something very personal and can ba argued upon, there are clear flaws in the tests: 1) the way how questions are being asked suggest answer to the questions asked above. 2) questions are sometimes not precise enough, e.g. in module 5:

"What is the average test score for students who were in special education during 1st grade?"

should be

"What is the average test score for students AFTER KINDERGARTEN who were in special education during 1st grade?"

교육 기관: Felipe C B

2018년 2월 20일

On one hand, it is a very concise course that gives you some insights about the topic in question without unnecesary details of some basic topics. I really appreciated this, as many coursera courses take a lot of classes on explaining a lot of extremely basics contents where you take a lot of time . On the other hand, I took away two stars because the contents are poorely delivered by the instructor and if you do not have a grasp on the topic, is almost impossible to understand what is the lesson about. Questions are way too specific about details of the lectures (even specific numbers), and not about the general topic covered.

교육 기관: Sophie W

2018년 12월 27일

The Professor has interpreted the course very detailed and thoroughly in terms of key methodologies and formulas. He also gave concrete examples and database to help me understand the theoretical knowledge. The quiz after each course are very helpful to understand new concepts and data implications in the examples. The only flaw might be too fast and not clear pronunciation of the instructor. Also, this is the only course about Impact Evaluation (i.e. RCT, IV, Diff-in-Diff) provided in Coursera. I hope there will be other similar courses available in Coursera!

교육 기관: Tiara A

2020년 6월 8일

Professor Holm provided a wealth of information in such a clear and succinct manner that learning the rigorous subject matter was not impossible. He provides the perfect balance of definitions and formulas along with interesting case studies. I highly recommend this course!

교육 기관: Aureliano A B

2018년 5월 16일

Great course! I finally understood the relation between RCT's, Instrumental Variables and DiDs. The prior suggested readings helped a lot, and the classes were very well conducted with intuitive explanations before the formal derivations that were also very helpful.

교육 기관: junseok k

2020년 4월 17일

I simply loved the lecture. I have considered to take other courses from Columbia University. But, it is much better for the beginner like me who have some statistical knowledge and no background in causal inference before. Thanking you very much.

교육 기관: Rohit V K

2018년 12월 13일

Good course with good explanation. But request please use a whiteboard instead of chalkboard in the background as the chalkboard becomes difficult to read on mobile devices. Some explanations can be augmented with additional reading

교육 기관: Andrej P

2020년 3월 29일

Causal effects in the Social sciences is a very difficult topic because experiments are often impossible in this field. This course provides some insightful techniques we can use to estimate a causal effect based on observed data.

교육 기관: Aedrian A

2021년 1월 11일

This is a challenging course, especially for those who only intend to breeze through the videos alone. Reading the recommended text before and/or after the videos is strongly advised.

교육 기관: Mohammad N A H

2020년 3월 12일

Some Reading Materials such as journal articles on similar methods covered in course would have been a great inclusion as a part of the exercises.

교육 기관: Aysha R

2019년 9월 11일

The course was well structured and helped to identify different approaches used to measure causality. Overall a well designed course.

교육 기관: niladri s b

2019년 2월 2일

This is a great course for people working in evaluating different social projects. Improved my insights a lot!

교육 기관: Eugenio D F

2017년 1월 8일

This is an useful course for medical researchs even though you can apply to other social science.

교육 기관: Olawoyin G A

2019년 1월 6일

I found it enlightening. It surely clarifies the concept of causality.

교육 기관: Jiacong L

2019년 11월 8일

Confusing concepts are presented clearly through examples. Thank you!

교육 기관: Sixtus A

2019년 1월 30일

Very useful course for people doing measurements in social sciences.

교육 기관: Николай Н

2019년 7월 16일

Отличный, специальный курс. Доступный но требует базовых знаний!

교육 기관: Vidya B R

2019년 1월 1일

Great material to review causal inference concepts.

교육 기관: Jie F

2019년 2월 13일

Very good short time course, highly recommended.

교육 기관: Lucas B

2018년 10월 30일

Very easy and intuitive

교육 기관: Monika B

2016년 12월 16일

Very good course!

교육 기관: Diego P

2017년 3월 2일

The course is great. Although it is really fast and requires some advanced understanding of algebra and statistics, it is not bad. However, I would reccommend to expand it and to include the advances in non-manipulative causation, as sustained by proff. J. Pearl and F. Squazzoni (specifically talking about sociology).

교육 기관: DR A N

2017년 9월 7일

The course covers many important topics with good examples but could have been longer and more detailed about various assumptions and their violations. The accent of the instructor and many algebraic notations are diificult to understand for non-mathematicians or non-statisticians like myself.