2018년 3월 31일
Amazing course, great instructors. The amount of working linear algebra knowledge you get from this single course is substantial. It has already helped solidify my learning in other ML and AI courses.
2018년 12월 22일
Professors teaches in so much friendly manner. This is beginner level course. Don't expect you will dive deep inside the Linear Algebra. But the foundation will become solid if you attend this course.
교육 기관: Miguel A F B•
2019년 3월 29일
This course is phenomenal, It helped me to refresh a lot of skills that I learned at my college and at the same time I learned a bit on how to introduce all this matrixes into a programming assignment which are by the way extremely hard because I am a novice at programming. It helped me to see other subitems such as Gramm Schmitt and eigenvectors that I did not see on college, I understood them but not a 100%, I guess an 75% is an average. Thanks Coursera and Imperial College London for this awesome course. I had to search other books to comprehend the subject, but next time, be more detailed.
교육 기관: Jeffrey J•
2018년 3월 8일
Course is titled incorrectly. The course has nothing to do with machine learning. It's mainly out of context symbol pushing (like most math courses).
I expect any positive reviews will be from folks who do not work as a practitioner in the field and just want to promote "good vibes". Beware if you're actually looking for contextualized understanding, as this is not the course for you (at least through the end of week 3).
교육 기관: Dharma T N•
2018년 5월 9일
This is indeed one of the best math courses I have ever done in my life. This course changed the view I look at matrices and vectors. I have been 'transformed'.
The instructors were simply amazing. Totally loved every bit of the course. Amazing way to teach this math course, with proper motivation and intuition.
And for all the people writing negative reviews about no Machine Learning being taught in this course, it is clearly mentioned that this course teaches the math which is required for learning Machine Learning and not Machine Learning itself.
교육 기관: Saswat B•
2018년 5월 9일
The content and the speed are not satisfactory.
The speed totally hampers the content, lots of things aren't explained especially after Sam took over in the last module.
Other than the first 2-3 intuition videos and the programming assignment nothing was good in the 5th module/week.
It was very very difficult to follow the page rank video. I still don't understand it. For eigen basis I had to refer to other material outside this course.
교육 기관: MARGARET P•
2020년 7월 31일
Why can't I give this course ZERO stars? Because that is what this course deserves.
The first course in the specialization was a train wreck. For starters, the videos were heavy on theory and light on examples, so when it came time to do the practice exams, each student needed to go to outside sources to learn, from the top, what they needed to do to complete the questions. This expectation is unacceptable. Secondly, no mention in the course information, videos, etc. was there any indication that there was coding. These coding assignments are delivered with no hint given as to what we would need to do, how, and why, which is entirely unacceptable. Lastly, the course creators are available nowhere. There are hundreds of questions on the forums for each week of each course, with not one answer coming from any of the course creators. I even went out of my way to find the email for the leading course creator and ask for additional resources/help but received zero response in return. I have been an avid supporter of Coursera for a long while now, but this specialization is terrible enough that I would consider never utilizing this site again. Mathematics for Machine Learning is an embarrassment to the entire service and devalues all of the work individuals have put into learning through this platform. It does this by diminishing the quality of the certificate by demeaning the level of competence acquired upon completion. If I were in charge of content, I would remove this specialization as well as thoroughly review all content published by the same institution. David Dye and the Imperial College of Londen should be ashamed.v
교육 기관: Nabil C•
2020년 10월 5일
First of all, the instructor clearly loves the subject he is teaching. You can tell immediately by the voice and the gestures.
Second, the fact that he is not a pure mathematician means he is constantly looking for the link between what he is teaching and practical examples. That's a must when you are teaching math to students intending to use it in real life (Machine Learning).
Third, there is a good structure to the material being taught, always building on what has previously been taught.
Fourth, is the amount of quizzes and exercises. Math can only be learned effectively if you keep challenging yourself in quantity and quality. Everyone remembers the quality bit, but some miss the quantity. Not this instructor I have to say. Congrats for that.
Fifth, intuition is being built from day one. Big applause for that as Linear Algebra lives and dies by the amount of intuition that's being put into its practice.
Sixth, my hat's off for the esthetic quality of the figures and exercises, and for their clarity.
Seventh, even for an engineer like me (graduated over 20 years ago I have to say) who's been best friends with Linear Algebra and Calculus for the 6 years I was in university (10 semesters + a final Master's thesis), this course wasn't trivial, and kept me making an effort at every bend, at every corner. This is something I am grateful for, as while I was refreshing concepts that I hadn't touched for 20 years now, I did have real fun.
Eighth, the coding examples are a magnificent tool that greatly helped strengthening some concepts (like Gram-Schmidth, etc.). Amazing job there.
Ninth, you can see how towards the end of the course, gears are shifted, pushing the student to get mental agility, and conveying the student the importance of intuition building (+ some algebraic symbolic manipulation) as opposite of focusing mainly on the symbolic manipulation. A good approach nowadays that computers do the computation for us, as opposite to what it used to be some decades ago. I really liked the fact that the instructors (Dr. Dye and Dr. Cooper) tried, both, to covey this very practical philosophical paradigm from day one.
My most sincere "cum laude" score for this course.
교육 기관: Timo K•
2018년 3월 28일
Amazing explanations of the covered topics, extremely engaging teaching staff
Focusses on the right things
Good and enough practice problems
Great (albeit easy) programming problems
Calculation of Eigenvectors could have been covered better in my opinion
A final handout for all the covered topics would be really nice
Overall a tremendous course if you want to brush up on linear algebra. To me LA was taught mostly doing rote calculations without motivating the concepts or explaining them geometrically. I had more than a handful of "oh, so that's how this actually works" moments. I feel like my intuitive understanding of linear algebra concepts has made a big improvement.
교육 기관: FRANCK R S•
2018년 4월 15일
I took a great pleasure to study this linear algebra course, teachers are very talented since their way to explain mathematical concepts make it very easy to understand , in fact with this particular amazing approach I changed my perception about learning math and sciences in general. I do recommend this course if you look for a global overview of linear algebra for direct application in machine learning or computer sciences!
교육 기관: Hussin E•
2021년 8월 9일
the instrutors were too good and their explination for the concepts was to the point and it made me realize things in linear algebra I didn't know before although I studied it in school of engineering
교육 기관: Laurent G•
2019년 4월 6일
A very good introduction but some of important content need to use another provider (Kahn academy) to understand completly
교육 기관: Mehregan K•
2021년 7월 27일
The instructors are good at teaching, but they don't teach you enough. so brace yourselves for long hours of looking at the screen, suffering from imposter syndrome. i truly am scared of taking the next courses.
교육 기관: Ashley W•
2019년 3월 31일
Lots of unaddressed inconsistencies.
교육 기관: Jorge N•
2018년 5월 2일
Mainly explains how to operate with matrices and vectors. Not how to use those in machine learning. If you expect to have a clear view of the usefulness of eigenvectors and eigenvalues in machine learning, this is not your course.
교육 기관: Keith D•
2022년 2월 27일
2 stars because this is not a beginner's course. false advertising. I'd recommend checking out some Khan academy videos on linear algebra and have at least a beginner's understanding of programming before attempting this course.
교육 기관: Badrul I•
2019년 2월 25일
Not intuitive or well explained. Examples are horrible
교육 기관: Mary B•
2021년 1월 29일
I only completed three out of the five weeks of this course. Too many of the lessons were just a source of frustration for me. The instructor doesn't explain things very well. For example, with change in vector basis, he walked us through using the dot product and scalar values, but then added them up. Nowhere did he say the last part was just a check, and it had me confused for quite a long time. Then, with Einstein's Summation Convention, he doesn't really explain the subscripts and what rules there are for their use. Plus, it's hard to follow along because he says the math out loud, then just writes down the answer. Since this is new to me, it would be good to see it written out, like | (1/2)(-2) + (-1)(4) |. Far too often, I had to rely on other resources to get enough of an understanding to complete the quizzes. By the fourth week, I started just skipping to the quiz and finding other resources to teach me how to solve the problems. Then, I decided to just give up entirely. And finally, there were issues with the auto-grader. With one, I needed to write out the values as 2.0 instead of 2, but there was no mention of needing this precision. With another, it was A[3, 0] (with a space) instead of A[3,0] (without a space), even though the provided code used A[1,0] (without a space).
교육 기관: Rob E•
2020년 8월 11일
I learned a lot of valuable concepts in this course. But, the pedagogy is very poor in my opinion. The videos are taught by Professor Implicit, the notation is inconsistent and confusing, and I never saw even one response to questions from the instructors.
Seems this is for people who have a very strong math background even though it's marked as an introductory course. It took me several months to complete this because I had to go through almost all of the Khan Academy Linear Algebra course to understand.
Great concept and content. But, responses to student questions and better explanations would help a lot.
교육 기관: Maria C F•
2021년 7월 30일
I feel like this course is underrated for people who want to learn machine learning. This, coming from someone who never did engineering degree. From the reviews seem like people were not satisfied with the lectures, but since week 1 they recommended plenty of Linear Algebra textbooks and Youtube. I like it because it encourages self-learning than being spoon-fed by the lectures. Not going to lie, this was the most challenging coursera course I have taken so far but that means I actually spent hours studying! My tips would be to watch the Youtube videos they recommend early in the course and attempt all the ungraded exercises. Utilize the discussion forum if you are stuck. I find the discussion forum and Youtube playlist really helped me grasp the concept. If you can get the textbooks, it's not necessary but they are also great study supplements
교육 기관: Bruno A•
2022년 6월 13일
Look, two recommendations about this course: this is a tough course! Especially if you've never seen Linear Algebra. Don't let this course be your first contact with Linear Algebra. If you do, at least take a famous reference book like Strang and follow the course with the book. Also, do not expect to watch the videos and understand the content magically. The course is full of assignments and challenging exercises, which are fundamental to having fun with the MOOC. This course helped me to review knowledge and, more than that, to develop new intuition about some topics in Linear Algebra. The instructors are great! The video production is really good! The pace, the assignments, the connection with Numpy and Python. I have only good things to say about this MOOC.
교육 기관: Derek T•
2022년 3월 24일
WARNING: This course is NOT for beginners. The requirement description is not true
Videos: This course is taught in a very dense way and fast that beginners may not be able to catch up. I saw many people in discussion forum complained about this.
Programming assignments: They are NOT for beginners too, assignments are not that something you can understand right away without basic coding knowledge (loop, else if, function, variable). If you don't know any of these, consider learning elsewhere before study this.
I'd recommend this course to those who already have fundamental knowledge in Linear Algebra or those want to revisit after time. The Lecturers taught Linear Algebra in both geometrical and algebra view, which help you understand better.
교육 기관: Marco G•
2019년 11월 10일
Great class to build an intuitive understanding of the concepts. The topics covered are not as many as in a serious course in linear algebra, but the ones covered really help you get to a genuine understanding. The assignment basically consist in rewriting in python what you see in the slides. If you are familiar even at a very basic level with Python, it will take you less than 5 minutes to complete the assignments, they are not challenging at all in that sense. But they do help visualize what is taught in the vides, which I guess is the purpose. To conclude, I would suggest paying for this course only if taking the full specialization, otherwise simply watch the videos for free!
교육 기관: John F•
2019년 6월 1일
This course is the first of 3 Machine Learning Math courses in this specialization which I am taking because I desperately need it as a refresh and as preparation to take Andrew Ng Machine Learning Course in the very near future. So I am 1/3 of the way there to being ready to take Andrew Ng famous and highly regarded Machine Learning Course. I began taking it but after 3 weeks, It became apparent that I needed this so that I can actually grasp and understand the material. I am so looking forward to starting it over again here shortly after I finish these next 2 fundamental prerequisites as I regard them
JeanPierre (John Fisher)
교육 기관: surendar r•
2019년 7월 21일
This course is absolutely stunning in terms of explaining mathematical concepts. I personally have been out of hands-on touch with mathematics for a decade, and by going through these videos, tutor has been absolutely spot on for me in bringing back my mathematical memories. Would highly recommend this course for anyone wanting to enhance their mathematical skills or brush up on mathematical concepts before doing deep dive in machine learning concepts. It really connects and I am enjoying this. Thanks for all these wonderful lectures.
교육 기관: Praveen D•
2019년 2월 2일
I found the course very interesting and useful. I really liked the approach of relating Linear Algebra to practical use. Traditional approach to teach Linear Algebra (which assumes some familiarity with Modern Algebra) may not be for everyone and the approach taken in the course will find much acceptance among curious learners. Thank you so much for putting this course together. May be, putting together a more detailed and longer course on Linear Algebra will be good idea - if it happens, i will be the first one to enroll !
교육 기관: Daniel R•
2019년 6월 4일
I have tried Linear Algebra via Gilbert Strang lectures before but found them unengaging because they are so abstracted. Here we see how the linear algebra applies directly to pageRank, which I found a cool example.
In general the questions allow for a good practice and build up, and I really appreciate the lecturers appreciation of the fact that hand-written calculus is becoming a thing of the past, and so we should focus on the big ideas behind the methods that are now so standardised for processing linear systems.]